NAD+ metabolism and its roles in cellular processes during ageing
Anthony J. Covarrubias, Rosalba Perrone, Alessia Grozio et al.
Research Article — Peer-Reviewed Source
Original research published by Covarrubias et al. in Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology. Redistributed under Open Access — see publisher for license terms. MedTech Research Group provides these references for informational purposes. We do not conduct original research. All studies are the work of their respective authors and institutions.
Abstract
Nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD + ) is a coenzyme for redox reactions, making it central to energy metabolism. NAD + is also an essential cofactor for non-redox NAD + -dependent enzymes, including sirtuins, CD38 and poly(ADP-ribose) polymerases. NAD + can directly and indirectly influence many key cellular functions, including metabolic pathways, DNA repair, chromatin remodelling, cellular senescence and immune cell function. These cellular processes and functions are critical for maintaining tissue and metabolic homeostasis and for healthy ageing. Remarkably, ageing is accompanied by a gradual decline in tissue and cellular NAD + levels in multiple model organisms, including rodents and humans. This decline in NAD + levels is linked causally to numerous ageing-associated diseases, including cognitive decline, cancer, metabolic disease, sarcopenia and frailty. Many of these ageing-associated diseases can be slowed down and even reversed by restoring NAD + levels. Therefore, targeting NAD + metabolism has emerged as a potential therapeutic approach to ameliorate ageing-related disease, and extend the human healthspan and lifespan. However, much remains to be learnt about how NAD + influences human health and ageing biology. This includes a deeper understanding of the molecular mechanisms that regulate NAD + levels, how to effectively restore NAD + levels during ageing, whether doing so is safe and whether NAD + repletion will have beneficial effects in ageing humans.
Cellular NAD + metabolism
NAD + is highly compartmentalized in the cytoplasm, mitochondria and nucleus, which represent its main subcellular pools ( Supplementary Box 1 ). These pools are regulated independently of each other, and consistent with this, the enzymes involved in the biosynthesis or degradation of NAD + are highly compartmentalized as well 2 – 4 . NAD + is a critical metabolite and coenzyme for multiple metabolic pathways and cellular processes. First, NAD + reduction is required to maintain energy balance and the redox state of a cell. NAD + is also continually turned over by three classes of NAD + -consuming enzymes: the NAD + glycohydrolases, also referred to as NADases (CD38, CD157 and SARM1), the protein deacylase family of sirtuins and PARPs, which have various important cellular functions. These utilize NAD + as a substrate or cofactor and generate nicotinamide (NAM) as a by-product ( FIG. 1 ). Therefore, NAD + mediates multiple major biological processes and is always in high demand ( Supplementary Boxes 2 and 3 ). To sustain NAD + levels, NAM can be recycled back to NAD + via the NAM salvage pathway (for details see BOX 1 ). Additionally, some cells, mostly in the liver, can synthesize NAD + de novo from multiple dietary sources. Thus, NAD + is constantly synthesized, catabolized and recycled in the cell to maintain stable intracellular NAD + levels ( FIG. 1 ). However, during ageing, this balance between catabolic and anabolic processes can shift, and NAD + degradation can outpace the ability of cells to make NAD + de novo or their ability to effectively recycle or salvage NAM. Furthermore, excess NAM may be catabolized via alternative metabolic pathways (for details see BOX 2 ), effectively diverting it away from the NAM salvage pathway and further impacting NAD + levels. Besides their common role as NAD + -consuming enzymes, NAD + glycohydrolases, sirtuins and PARPs have distinct roles in ageing and age-related diseases. While enhancing the activation of sirtuins has emerged as a way to increase lifespan and healthspan, aberrant activation of PARPs and NAD + glycohydrolases, such as CD38, may exert the opposite effect and exacerbate ageing phenotypes (see later). NAD + biosynthetic pathways NAD + can be made de novo from l -tryptophan via the kynurenine pathway or from vitamin precursors, such as nicotinic acid (NA), via the Preiss–Handler pathway ( FIG. 1a ). In addition to NAD + , the kynurenine pathway also utilizes l -tryptophan to produce kynurenic acid, serotonin and picolinic acid, among other bioactive molecules. Notably, the relative contribution of the de novo synthesis pathway to NAD + levels is still not well understood. Outside the liver, most cells do not express the full array of enzymes necessary to convert tryptophan to NAD + by the kynurenine pathway. Most tryptophan is metabolized to NAM in the liver, where it is released into the serum, taken up by peripheral cells and converted to NAD + by the NAM salvage pathway 5 . Additionally, under some circumstances, immune cells, such as macrophages, also make NAD + from tryptophan (discussed later) 6 . Thus, besides the liver, the de novo biosynthetic pathway seems to be a more indirect mechanism contributing to system-wide NAD + levels, with most NAD + coming from the NAM salvage pathway ( BOX 1 ).
NAD + consumption routes
Consumption by sirtuins. Since their discovery, the sirtuins have received much attention because they regulate key metabolic processes, stress responses and ageing biology 7 . The mammalian sirtuin family is composed of seven genes and proteins (SIRT1–SIRT7) with different subcellular localizations (nucleus for SIRT1 and SIRT6; nucleolus for SIRT7; mitochondria for SIRT3, SIRT4 and SIRT5; and cytosol for SIRT1, SIRT2 and SIRT5) ( FIG. 1b ), enzymatic activities and downstream targets. The sub-cellular localization of these NAD + -dependent enzymes emphasizes how local fluctuations of intracellular NAD + pools, which are themselves regulated by sirtuins, may selectively impact organelle-specific sirtuin functions and cellular metabolism. Sirtuins are continuously active in our cells. SIRT1 and SIRT2 seem to be responsible for about one third of the total NAD + consumption under basal conditions 5 . Moreover, a rise of NAD + levels is strongly correlated with sirtuin activation during fasting and caloric restriction 8 , 9 . It is also worth noting that sirtuin activity is coupled to the circadian clock, whereby SIRT1 and SIRT6 regulate the activity of the core clock transcription factors and downstream circadian transcriptome 8 . In addition, SIRT1 and a key enzyme of the NAD + salvage pathway, nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT) ( BOX 1 ), are key players in the circadian regulation of NAD + levels, and NAMPT is regulated by the circadian clock, which provides a feedback loop, resulting in circadian oscillation of NAD + levels 10 , 11 . Early studies in yeast demonstrated roles of sirtuins in gene silencing, which in 2000 was attributed to their activity as NAD + -dependent deacetylases 12 . Sirtuin enzymatic activity was initially reported to encompass mainly removal of an acetyl group from lysine residues of target proteins in a two-step process: first NAD + is cleaved to NAM and ADP-ribose, and second, the acetyl group on the target protein is transferred to ADP-ribose, allowing the formation of the intermediate peptidyl-ADP-ribose. Acetyl-ADP-ribose is subsequently released ( FIG. 2a ). Additionally, some members of the sirtuin family mediate non-acetyl lysine acylations (for example, succinylation, malonylation and fatty acid acylation) 13 – 15 , the cellular functions of which are so far poorly understood 16 . SIRT4 and SIRT6 also function as ADP-ribosyltransferases, indicating that sirtuins contribute to cell regulation also through mechanisms beyond modulation of protein acetylation, which require further investigation 17 , 18 . Although measuring NAD + levels and sirtuin activity in subcellular compartments has been hampered by technological challenges, owing to recent technical advancements ( Supplementary Box 4 ) we now have some insights into distinct cellular roles of these enzymes. Specifically, recent evidence has shown that nuclear SIRT1, SIRT6 and SIRT7 are critical regulators of DNA repair and genome stability and that mitochondrial SIRT3, SIRT4 and SIRT5 and nuclear SIRT1 regulate mitochondrial homeostasis and metabolism 7 . In apparent contrast with its role in promoting mitochondrial biogenesis through peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-γ co-activator 1α deacetylation 19 – 21 , SIRT1 has also been implicated in turnover of defective mitochondria by mitophagy 22 , 23 . However, in both cases SIRT1 seems to be a key factor in mitochondrial quality maintenance 9 . Overall, sirtuins have emerged as key actors in the efforts to understand and characterize how NAD + levels affect cellular homeostasis in a wide variety of cellular processes that impact ageing ( Supplementary Box 2 ), and boosting their activity is a key focus of therapies aimed at counteracting ageing.
Consumption by PARPs.
The human PARP protein family is composed of 17 proteins characterized by poly(ADP-ribosyl) polymerase or mono(ADP-ribosyl) polymerase activity 24 . Briefly, the PARP-mediated cleavage of NAD + produces NAM and ADP-ribose as by-products, in which ADP-ribose is added as single or covalently linked polymers to PARP itself and other acceptor proteins, in a process called ‘poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation’ (PARylation) ( FIG. 2b ). Among all the PARPs, only PARP1, PARP2 and PARP3 localize to the nucleus ( FIG. 1b ) in response to early DNA damage and have a key role in DNA damage repair 25 – 27 ( Supplementary Box 2 ). PARP1 is the best-characterized member of the group, and it alone is responsible for about 90% of total PARP activity at least in response to DNA damage 28 , 29 . On activation, PARP1 PARylates itself along with histones and other proteins that act as a scaffold to recruit and activate other DNA repair enzymes and proteins to the lesion site to initiate DNA repair 30 . Owing to high PARP1 activity, DNA damage is associated with massive NAD + consumption. PARP1, in its role as an NAD + responsive signalling molecule, has been widely associated with the ageing process. However, PARP1 is one of the major NAD + consumers not only in cells with acute DNA damage but also under normal and other pathophysiological conditions 5 , supporting a key role of PARP1 in regulating NAD + homeostasis. For example, in mice fed a high-fat diet, those that were treated with PARP inhibitors or lacking PARP1 and PARP2 had increased NAD + levels, increased SIRT1 activity and improved mitochondrial function, and were protected from insulin resistance 31 , 32 . The strong correlation among PARP1 activation, decline in NAD + levels and inhibition of SIRT1 activity is observed in patients with xeroderma pigmentosum group A, as well as progeroid diseases, ataxia telangiectasia and Cockayne syndrome. Notably, treatment of mice with Cockayne syndrome with PARP1 inhibitors or NAD + supplements promoted lifespan extension and ameliorated the severe phenotypes caused by PARP1 hyperactivation, providing strong evidence that the negative consequences downstream of PARP1 activation are mediated by dysregulation of NAD + homeostasis in response to extensive DNA damage and genotoxic stress 33 . Of note, the ability of PARP1 to antagonize SIRT1 activity is most likely because these enzymes are localized to the same cellular compartment — in this case, the nucleus — and compete for the same NAD + pool. However, since PARP1 has lower K m and higher V max with regard to NAD + than SIRT1, PARP1 likely outcompetes SIRT1 for NAD + as a result of its greater binding affinity and faster kinetics 34 . PARP2 is structurally related to PARP1. They share a similar catalytic domain required for several cellular processes, including DNA repair and transcriptional regulation, and account for about 10% of PARP activity 35 . PARP2 activity may also influence NAD + bioavailability 25 , 26 . Like Parp1 -knockout mice, Parp2 -knockout mice show enhanced SIRT1 activity and improved metabolic function, and are protected from high-fat diet-induced obesity 36 . PARP3 is important in DNA repair as well 27 , suggesting a large overlap and potential redundancy in PARP1, PARP2 and PARP3. The functions of the other PARPs (PARP4–PARP17) in NAD + homeostasis and global metabolism in cells or organs have not been fully determined, but they are thought to be less important in modulating intracellular NAD + levels. Overall, targeting PARPs, and in particular PARP1, is a promising therapeutic strategy in the ageing field. However, more studies are needed to fully understand the contribution of PARPs to the age-related decline in NAD + levels.
Consumption by CD38 and CD157.
CD38 and CD157 are multifunctional ectoenzymes with both glycohydrolase and ADP-ribosyl cyclase activities. The glycohydrolysis of NAD + is the primary catalytic reaction that cleaves the glycosidic bond within NAD + to generate NAM and ADP-ribose, whereas the ADP-ribosyl cyclase activity generates cyclic ADP-ribose ( FIG. 2c ). CD38 also performs a base-exchange reaction, by swapping the NAM of NAD(P) + for NA in acidic conditions and generating nicotinic acid adenine dinucleotide (phosphate) (NAAD(P)) 37 ( FIG. 2c ). Of note, cyclic ADP-ribose, NAAD(P) and ADP-ribose are all key Ca 2+ -mobilizing second messengers, illustrating the pivotal role of CD38 in activating Ca 2+ signalling and modulating essential cell processes, such as immune cell activation, survival and metabolism 38 – 40 . Importantly, other than NAD + and NADP + , NMN is emerging as an alternative substrate of CD38 (REFS 41 , 42 ), whereas CD157 consumes NR as an alternative substrate 43 , 44 ( FIG. 2c ). Thus, targeting CD38 and CD157 with small-molecule inhibitors may make these commonly used NAD + precursor metabolites more efficient in restoring NAD + levels in ageing individuals. Very little is known about the purpose of CD157 enzymatic functions in cellular biology or ageing. However, recent evidence shows that, like CD38, CD157 is upregulated in ageing tissues 45 and may have a role in ageing-related diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis and cancer 46 . Although CD38 and CD157 are genetically homologous and are members of the same enzymatic family, their structure, localization and role in diseases differ. CD38 is a transmembrane protein with a type ii orientation and/or a type III orientation identified in the late 1970s as a T cell activation marker but now known to be ubiquitously expressed, particularly during inflammation 47 , 48 . CD157 is a glycophosphatidylinositol-anchored protein, which was first identified in the myeloid compartment of the haematopoietic system 49 . However, CD157 is also expressed by other cells, including B cell progenitors, Paneth cells and endothelial cells in the gut, pancreas and kidney 50 . Besides their enzymatic function, CD38 and CD157 act as cell receptors. For example, CD38 is an adhesion receptor interacting with CD31 to mediate immune cell trafficking and extravasation through the endothelium 51 , 52 . The CD38–CD31 axis seems to promote a proliferative response in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia lymphocytes, suggesting a detrimental role of CD38 in blood cancers 53 , 54 (see Supplementary Box 3 ). However, very little is known about the functional consequences of CD38–CD31 interaction. Additionally, CD38 is thought to mediate immunity through antimicrobial functions, given that a major phenotype of Cd38 -knockout mice is their inability to mount immune responses to bacteria 55 . It is still unknown whether the CD38 enzymatic function is necessary for its antibacterial functions and to what extent these functions depend on NAD + . However, it is plausible that the role of CD38 in antimicrobial resistance is related to sequestering NAD + or NAD + -related metabolites from bacteria that require NAD + for survival and growth 56 , 57 . The role of CD157 as a receptor is still not fully explored. Several lines of evidence suggest that CD157 activation by specific monoclonal antibodies promotes trafficking of neutrophils and monocytes 58 . Moreover, CD157 interacts with integrins to form a receptor recognized by scrapie-responsive gene 1 protein (SCRG1), promoting self-renewal, migration and osteogenic differentiation of human mesenchymal stem cells 43 . However, whether these receptor functions are relevant to NAD + metabolism remain unclear.
Consumption by SARM1.
SARM1 was only very recently assigned to the NAD + glycohydrolase and cyclase family along with CD38 and CD157. The enzymatic activity of SARM1 ( FIG. 2c ) relies on the Toll/interleukin receptor (TIR) domain that was previously not known to possess catalytic activity and generally to be involved in protein–protein interaction 59 . Whether SARM1 regulates NAD + under physiological conditions and to what extent is still unknown. However, SARM1-mediated NAD + degradation plays a key role in axonal degeneration after axonal injury 60 (see the section Neurodegeneration ). SARM1 is primarily expressed in neurons and promotes neuronal morphogenesis and inflammation 61 , 62 ; however, SARM1 is also expressed by immune cells such as macrophages and T lymphocytes, and regulates their functions 63 – 65 . SARM1 was originally discovered as a negative regulator of the innate immune response via direct interaction with TRIF (TIR domain-containing adapter protein inducing interferon-β), downstream of Toll-like receptor signalling 63 . However, the immunoregulatory role of SARM1 remains largely uncharacterized. Although SARM1 was originally reported to be required for chemokine CCL5 production in macrophages 66 , recent evidence revealed that SARM1 is not expressed in macrophages and that the observed chemokine phenotype was due to a background effect of the Sarm1 -knockout mouse strain 67 . Despite its controversial role in immune cells, SARM1 plays an undisputed key role in axonal degeneration and is emerging as a therapeutic target to prevent or ameliorate neurodegenerative diseases and traumatic brain injuries (as discussed in the section Neurodegeneration ).
Cellular roles of NAD +
Beyond the main groups of NAD + - Beyond the main groups of NAD + -consuming enzymes discussed so far, NAD + is widely used as a cofactor or substrate for biochemical reactions, with more than 300 enzymes 1 relying on NAD + for their activity. Accordingly, NAD + is a mediator of key cellular functions and adaptation to metabolic needs. Some of these critical cellular processes include metabolic pathways, redox homeostasis, maintenance and repair of DNA to safeguard genomic stability, epigenetic regulation and chromatin remodelling, and autophagy. Collectively, these functions are important for maintaining systemic health and homeostasis. However, during ageing, declining NAD + levels can impinge on these processes and exacerbate ageing-related diseases ( FIG. 3 ; Supplementary Box 2 ).
NAD + -dependent mechanisms in ageing
During ageing, NAD + levels decline, and many enzymes associated with NAD + degradation and biosynthesis are altered. The relationship between NAD + and the 10 hallmarks of ageing was extensively reviewed 68 (see also Supplementary Table 1 ). Additionally, this decline in NAD + levels during ageing has been linked to the development and progression of ageing-related diseases, including atherosclerosis, arthritis, hypertension, cognitive decline, diabetes and cancer 3 . In this section, we focus on the major cellular processes that influence or are influenced by ageing, such as metabolic dysfunction, DNA repair failure and genomic instability, inflammageing, cellular senescence and neurodegeneration, and discuss their regulation by NAD + levels. All these processes and the age-related disorders associated with them are likely to benefit from NAD + repletion. Restoring NAD + levels with dietary precursors and targeting NAD + degradation enzymes with small-molecule inhibitors has emerged as a potential therapeutic strategy to restore NAD + levels, thereby providing opportunities for alleviating age-related decline and diseases ( FIG. 4 ) (see also the next section). Metabolic dysfunction Obesity is a growing epidemic worldwide 69 . Individuals with obesity are more likely to develop metabolic disease characterized by increased adiposity, insulin resistance, high blood glucose levels, high blood pressure and dyslipidaemia. As a result, these individuals are at higher risk of developing type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease, non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, atherosclerosis, stroke and cancer 70 . Accordingly, obesity accelerates and exacerbates ageing, and has been associated with shortened lifespan 71 . Over the past two decades growing evidence has accumulated that targeting NAD + metabolism may provide therapeutic benefits and help treat metabolic disease and ageing 3 . NAD + was first discovered by regulating the metabolic rates of yeast extracts, and thus the links between NAD + and metabolism have been known for almost a century. We now know that NAD + lies at the heart of metabolism and regulates metabolic flux of multiple metabolic pathways (for details see BOX 1 and Supplementary Box 2 ). Accordingly, NAD + homeostasis is required for the proper function of various metabolic tissues, including fat, muscle, intestines, kidneys and liver (reviewed in 72 ). However, another key discovery was made more recently in Saccharomyces cerevisiae , showing that the longevity protein Sir2 (the yeast sirtuin) exhibited its lifespan-promoting effects in an NAD + -dependent manner 12 , 73 , 74 . This breakthrough finding suggested that Sir2 activity may be linked to metabolic status. In support of this hypothesis, it has now been demonstrated in mammalian systems that lifespan-extending metabolic manipulations, such as exercise 75 – 77 , caloric restriction 78 , time-restricted feeding and a ketogenic diet 79 , as well as healthy circadian rhythms 1 , 11 (including regular sleep patterns 80 ), work in part by increasing NAD + levels, which leads to the activation of sirtuins. Altering or disrupting metabolic status, for example as a consequence of a high-fat diet 81 , 82 , postpartum weight loss 83 and disruption of the circadian rhythm 1 , 83 , can lead to lower NAD + levels, and thereby reduced activity of sirtuins as well as other NAD + -dependent cellular processes (see Supplementary Box 2 for details). Conversely, increasing cellular NAD + levels has recently been shown to reduce reductive stress and drive the directionailty of metabolic reactions 84 . Additionally, higher NAD + levels can promote the deacetylase and deacylase activity of both nuclear SIRT1 and mitochondrial SIRT3, which regulate mitochondrial function and protect from high-fat diet-induced metabolic disease 42 , 81 , 85 – 88 . Taken together, these key studies have provided strong evidence and the rationale that targeting NAD + degradation pathways or boosting NAD + levels can influence metabolic processes and can be protective against metabolic disease. In further support of this model, numerous studies have now shown that mouse models including Parp1 -knockout and Cd38 -knockout mice, or mice treated with PARP or CD38 inhibitors, have supraphysiological levels of NAD + . They are also protected from obesity, have increased metabolic rates and have (relatively) normal glucose metabolism during high-fat diet conditions and during ageing 42 , 89 – 91 . Additionally, mice receiving a high-fat diet have increased inflammation, which drives decreased expression of NAMPT, and reduced activity of the NAD + salvage pathway 82 ( BOX 1 ), providing a potential mechanistic explanation for why NAD + levels decline during obesity. In line with this mechanism, mice with adipocyte-specific deletion of NAMPT have lower levels of NAD + in their fat tissues, increased insulin resistance and increased metabolic dysfunction, which can be rescued with NMN supple
Deregulation of immune cell function
Inflammageing is now being recognized as a hallmark of ageing and a key driver of disease ( FIG. 3Aa ), including ageing-associated diseases, and has been described as a prominent risk factor for morbidity and death 95 – 97 . Chronic inflammation has profound effects on systemic metabolism, via a complicated crosstalk between immune cells and metabolic cells, such as hepatocytes and adipocytes, influencing metabolic processes such as glucose and lipid uptake, and insulin sensitivity 96 . Despite the increased interest in immunometabolism in the last decade, little is known about how NAD + influences chronic inflammation and immune cell function. We will discuss the emerging picture next. Innate immunity. Chronic low-grade inflammation, characterized by aberrant activation of the innate immune system, enhanced expression of proinflammatory cytokines, such as tumour necrosis factor (TNF), IL-6 and IL-1β, and activation of immune complexes, such as the NLRP3 inflammasome, is now being recognized as a key driver of ageing-related and metabolic diseases. Additionally, it is now emerging that altered macrophage activation and phenotypic polarization is a key source of this inflammation. For example, in obese tissues such as the visceral fat, peripheral monocytes are recruited by stressed adipocytes, leading to a progressive infiltration of proinflammatory M1-like macrophages and the displacement of the resident, anti-inflammatory M2 macrophages 96 . This switch in macrophage polarization states in the visceral fat is accompanied by enhanced expression of proinflammatory cytokines, insulin resistance and reduced rates of lipolysis. Elie Metchnikoff, the discoverer of the macrophage, was the first to observe the increased abundance of macrophages in ageing tissues more than 100 years ago. Although this observation was initially disregarded, there is now growing evidence that ageing not only leads to increased macrophage abundance but is also accompanied by altered macrophage polarization state and function, which is emerging as a key driver of inflammageing 98 , 99 . Some of the earliest work suggesting that NAD + affects macrophage function showed that inhibition of NAMPT and subsequent depletion of NAD + pools in macrophages decreased the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines, such as TNF, and caused morphological changes, such as reduced spreading in these cells 100 , 101 . Recent studies have shown that NAD + is a critical regulator of macrophage function and that macrophage activation is associated with the upregulation of NAD + biosynthetic or degradative pathways, depending on the acquired fate. For example, our laboratory recently showed that proinflammatory (M1) macrophage polarization is associated with enhanced expression of CD38, leading to increased NAD + consumption 45 . Conversely, anti-inflammatory (M2) macrophage polarization was associated with an increase in NAD + levels that depended on NAMPT 45 . Blocking the NAM salvage pathway ( BOX 1 ) in both M1 macrophages and M2 macrophages significantly reduced gene expression of select genes associated with the M1 and M2 phenotypes. This effect could be rescued with supplementation with the NAD + precursors NMN and NR, which bypass and rescue NAMPT inhibition 45 . M2 macrophages required significantly more NR/NMN to rescue macrophage activation than M1 macrophages, suggesting that NAD + is a critical metabolite for general macrophage activation, and its metabolism is differentially regulated to control distinct biological processes and functions in M1 and M2 macrophages. Consistent with our results, a recent study found that M1 macrophage polarization is associated with enhanced degradation of NAD + and that inhibiting NAMPT blocks glycolytic shifts in M1 macrophages, limiting proinflammatory responses in vitro and reducing systemic inflammation in vivo in response to sepsis 102 . This study and another recent report 6 , 102 suggest that this NAD + turnover, particularly during the first few hours of macrophage M1 polarization, depends on reactive oxygen species-induced DNA damage and activation of PARP1. However, recently published results from our laboratory detected no evidence of DNA damage or PARP1 activation during M1 macropahge polarization 45 . By contrast, our results suggest that CD38 is the primary NAD + -consuming enzyme in M1 macrophages. These results are consistent with recent work showing that M1 macrophages are protected from reactive oxygen species-induced DNA damage as a result of increased transcription of genes involved in antioxidant defence, such as SOD2 (REFS 102 – 104 ). Thus, these contradictory observations highlight a need to better delineate the major consumers of NAD + during proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory macrophage polarization to determine whether the observed decline in NAD + levels depends on context and time and to determine the molecular mechanisms through which NAD + levels influence proinflammatory and anti
Adaptive immunity.
Like for the innate immune system, ageing is characterized by a reduced ability to build an effective adaptive immune response due to altered functions of adaptive immune cells, known as immunosenescence. Ageing leads to an imbalance or skewing of immune cell populations, including decreased levels of naive T and B cells, loss of T cell antigen receptor diversity and an increase in levels of virtual memory T cells. The regulatory role of NAD + and NAD + -consuming enzymes in T cell biology has been demonstrated; however, their contribution to the ageing of the adaptive immunity is largely uncharacterized. On the one hand, extracellular NAD + has been proposed as a danger signal 110 causing cell death in specific T cell subpopulations, such as regulatory T cells 111 . On the other hand, NAD + seems to exhibit immunomodulatory properties, such as influencing T cell polarization 112 , 113 . However, whether NAD + promotes a specific T cell phenotype and whether the manipulation of NAD + metabolism with NAD + precursors could result in similar immunomodulatory properties is still unknown. An established hallmark of adaptive immune ageing is the expansion of the memory population of highly cytotoxic CD8 + CD28 − T cells 114 , characterized by high secretion of effector molecules such as granzyme B 115 . This cell population is characterized by decreased SIRT1 and FOXO1 levels, resulting in an enhanced glycolytic capacity and granzyme B production 116 . These studies highlight the potential of metabolic reprogramming via manipulation of NAD + -associated pathways in age-related adaptive immune dysfunction 116 . The upregulation of the NAD + –SIRT1–FOXO1 axis via CD38 inhibition increases effector functions in T helper 1 and 17 hybrid cells 117 , and future studies using CD38 inhibitors or NAD + precursors may potentially show the therapeutic potential of targeting NAD + in the ageing adaptive immune system. Another immunological feature of adaptive immune ageing is the increase in the number of exhausted T cells, characterized by the expression of inhibitory receptor molecules (for example, PD1 and TIM3), decreased proliferative capacity and decreased effector functions 118 , 119 . PD1 is a component of the immune checkpoint, blockade of which is commonly used as an anticancer strategy 120 , 121 , but also has been proposed to restore the effector function of aged T cells 122 . With respect to NAD + metabolism, a recent study showed that CD38 overexpression was associated with a dysfunctional and exhausted CD8 T population in PD1 blockade-resistant cancers 123 , 124 , highlighting the potential of expanding studies on CD38 inhibition to age-related exhausted T cells. However, although extremely intriguing, this hypothesis is yet to be explored in depth, and more studies will be needed to determine the preclinical efficacy of this approach. Thus, overall, more work needs to be done to determine whether manipulating NAD + levels is effective in reversing ageing-related immunological dysfunction in the adaptive immune system and, equally important, whether such manipulations are safe.
Cellular senescence
During ageing, cells exposed to metabolic, genotoxic or oncogene-induced stress undergo essentially irreversible cell cycle arrest known as cellular senescence. One major phenotype of senescent cells and how they are thought to promote disease is the increased expression of inflammatory mediators, mostly cytokines and chemokines, known as the senescence-associated secretory phenotype (SASP), which contributes to impaired tissue homeostasis by interfering with stem cell regeneration, tissue and wound repair and inflammageing 125 , 126 ( FIG. 3Aa ). As the numbers of senescent cells gradually increase with age, cellular senescence has been linked to several age-associated diseases, and clearance of senescent cells with pharmacologic senolytics may be an effective treatment for several previously untreatable diseases, including Alzheimer disease 127 – 129 . In addition, treatments aimed at boosting cellular NAD + levels during ageing are promising targets for extending healthspan 130 , but how NAD + impacts cellular senescence is not clear. It was recently shown that senescent cells upregulate the expression of the NAM salvage enzyme NAMPT ( BOX 1 ) and that the SASP of senescent cells depends on NAD + levels 131 . Treating senescent cells with NMN can heighten the SASP, leading to increased chronic inflammation, and can promote the development of inflammation-driven cancers. These findings suggest that administration of NAD + -boosting supplements, such as NR and NMN, may come at the cost of long-term side effects, such as enhancing chronic inflammation and cancer development. Thus, a greater understanding of the benefits and unattended side effects of boosting NAD + levels will be an important area of focus in future studies and ongoing clinical trials. As inflammation is a very complex and multipurpose process, additional studies are needed to better understand how NAD + levels influence different inflammatory states and in what context, and to determine how, mechanistically, NAD + metabolism impacts the biology of inflammatory immune and senescent cells. Despite well-documented observations of senescent cells accumulating in ageing tissues and the concomitant decline of NAD + levels in these tissues, no studies link the accumulation of inflammatory senescent cells to NAD + levels during ageing. Recently, it was shown that CD38 levels increase in mammalian tissues with age, and CD38 has been proposed to be the major NAD + -consuming enzyme responsible for the decline in NAD + levels during ageing 42 , 91 . However, the mechanisms driving increased CD38 expression in aged tissues and which cells express CD38 in these tissues are unclear. Recent observations suggest that innate immune cells, especially macrophages, may be the major cell population responding to the SASP with NAD + degradation, thereby contributing to organism-wide decline in NAD + levels 45 , 105 . We showed that macrophages co-cultured in or exposed to conditioned media from senescent cells have enhanced expression of the NAD + -consuming enzyme CD38 and increased proliferation 45 . Importantly, another group has also independently shown that senescent cells and their SASP activate CD38 expression and promote CD38-dependent NADase activity in macrophages 105 , 106 . Furthermore, we showed in ageing mouse models and mice treated with the senescence-inducing chemotherapeutic reagent doxorubicin that accumulation of senescent cells in metabolic tissues, such as the visceral fat and liver, can directly activate the expression of CD38 in tissue-resident macrophages 45 . In further support of the connection between inflammageing, senescent cell burden and NAD + , a recent study in mice has also shown that cells with dysfunctional mitochondria initiate a proinflammatory programme, with the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines. This was associated with greater senescent cell burden, increased metabolic and physical dysfunction, and premature ageing 132 . In this context, supplementation with NR was able to partially rescue this multimorbidity syndrome, in part by reducing inflammation and senescent cell burden 132 — in contrast to the finding discussed above that NAD + precursors can increase SASP expression 131 . Thus, regulation of senescence by NAD + appears to be complex. Overall, these findings suggest that targeting immune cells such as T cells, macrophages and senescent cells should be considered in approaches aiming to restore NAD + levels during ageing. However, until more is known about the long-term side effects of enhancing NAD + levels, this work should proceed with caution.
Neurodegeneration
Ageing is strongly associated with most neurodegenerative diseases and is accompanied by decreased cellular NAD + levels in the mammalian brain 133 . NAD + depletion is reported in several models of accelerated ageing which exhibit neurodegeneration 33 , 134 , 135 , as well as in neuro-degenerative diseases, including Alzheimer disease 136 , Parkinson disease 137 , 138 and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) 139 . The underlying cause and mechanisms of NAD + loss in the brain during age-related neurodegenerative diseases are still largely unknown. However, multiple lines of evidence support a neuroprotective role for NAD + ( FIG. 3Ab ). First, axonal degeneration, which is a precursor to many age-related neuronal disorders 140 , 141 , is characterized by rapid NAD + depletion. During normal physiological conditions, the NAD + biosynthetic enzyme nicotinamide mononucleotide adenylyltransferase 2 (NMNAT2) ( FIG. 1 ; BOX 1 ) is a survival factor in axons, in which it needs to be constantly replenished via anterograde axonal transport due to its rapid turnover 142 . However, during axon degeneration, NMNAT2 axonal transport is blocked, and the axonal pool of the protein is rapidly degraded, leading to a critical depletion of NAD + in the axon 142 , 143 . Moreover, the NAD + -consuming enzyme SARM1 is activated by axonal injury and mediates axonal degeneration by promoting NAD + degradation 60 . This was originally shown in Wallerian degeneration slow ( Wld s ) mice, which are protected from axonal degeneration, showing absence of SARM1 expression 144 and higher neuronal NAD + levels, owing to the overexpression of a chimeric fusion protein of NMNAT1, which allows its redistribution from the nucleus to the axon, where it can substitute for the activity of NMNAT2 (REFS 145 , 146 ). The role of SARM1 in promoting axonal damage has been demonstrated in several other in vivo models. Sarm1 -knockout mice are protected from axonal degeneration 60 and can rescue the severe axon growth defects and perinatal death induced by lack of NMNAT2 (REFS 147 , 148 ). Recently, a transgenic mouse model overexpressing a dominant negative version of SARM1 in neurons showed a significant delay in axon degeneration and hints at the promising effect of gene therapy or small molecules targeting SARM1 for treating neuropathies 149 . Overall, Wld s mouse studies largely show the neuro protective function of the biosynthetic enzymes NMNAT1, NMNAT2 and NMNAT3 (REFS 142 , 150 – 152 ) and their protective role in several neurodegenerative disorders, including Parkinson disease 153 – 155 . However, the mechanism remains unclear. Besides the regulation of SARM1-dependent NAD + degradation discussed above, the degradation of their substrate and NAD + precursor, NMN, by NMNATs seems to protect axons from degeneration. In contrast to the neuroprotective role of NAD + , the precursor NMN has been reported to have a neurotoxic role promoting SARM1 activation and cyclic ADP-ribose generation, leading to axonal destruction 156 . However, the evidence that NMN accumulation leads to axonal degeneration needs to be validated and remains controversial. Nonetheless, this possibility raises questions about the therapeutic potential of increasing NAD + synthesis by supplementing NAD + precursors such as NMN. Additional lines of evidence supporting a neuroprotective role for NAD + also include studies using P7C3, an aminopropyl carbazole reported to be an allosteric activator of NAMPT in the NAM salvage pathway ( BOX 1 ). P7C3 was shown to be neuroprotective in mouse models of Parkinson disease 137 , Alzheimer disease 157 and ALS 158 . Furthermore, NAD + -consuming enzymes other than SARM1 have been reported to play a role in intracellular NAD + depletion during ageing-related neurodegenerative diseases. For example, CD38 expression increases in the course of Alzheimer disease progression 159 – 161 , and an Alzheimer disease mouse model lacking CD38 ( Cd38 -knockout mice), which results in elevated NAD + levels in their brains, shows a milder disease phenotype 159 . Consistent with the neuroprotective role of NAD + , Cd38 -knockout mice are also protected from neuronal cell death on ischaemic brain injury 162 . Multiple cells in the brain, including microglia, astrocytes, neurons and endothelial cells, express CD38 (REFS 108 , 160 ), and treating microglia and astrocytes with inflammatory cytokines induces CD38 expression 163 , 164 . Consistent with this finding, CD38 expression was associated with neuroinflammation with greater amounts of proinflammatory macrophages/microglia in mouse brains 160 , 165 . CD38 was also reported to affect social behaviour, as was its homologue CD157 (REFS 166 , 167 ), substantiating the functional impact of NAD + on neuronal function. Although there is no direct evidence of a causal role of CD38 in neurodegenerative diseases, as discussed above, CD38 is emerging as a key enzyme involved in inflammageing and senescence 45 , 105
Therapeutic targeting of NAD + level decline
Over the past two decades, the importance of NAD + in healthy ageing and longevity has been recognized. Preclinical studies in different animal models, such as Caenorhabditis elegans , D. melanogaster , rodents and human primary cells, have firmly established that there is an age-dependent decline of NAD + levels, which ranges from 10% to 65%, depending on different organs and age 130 . NAD + can be regulated by dietary and lifestyle choices ( FIG. 4 ). It can also be modulated pharmacologically, and so far, three main approaches have been explored to increase NAD + levels: dietary supplementation with NAD + precursors involved in the salvage pathways of NAD + ; modulation of NAD + biosynthetic enzymes, in particular those that regulate the rate-limiting step of de novo synthesis and salvage pathways (α-amino-β-carboxymuconate ε-semialdehyde decarboxylase (ACMSD) and NAMPT, respectively); and the inhibition of enzymes involved in NAD + degradation, such as PARPs and CD38. Augmentation of NAD + levels has shown efficacy in a variety of mouse models of human diseases ( TABLE 1 ), leading to numerous clinical trials of NAD + boosters in humans during ageing ( TABLE 2 ). Considering the scope of this Review, we will not detail the NAD + -related clinical trials and we refer the reader to more comprehensive reviews of this topic 68 , 183 , 184 . Most of the preclinical studies in rodents suggest a strong translational potential for NAD + -boosting therapies. Studies in humans are less advanced, and to date the clinical trials evaluating the pharmacokinetics and toxicology of NAD + precursors have primarily demonstrated that NMN and NR administration is safe and can efficiently increase NAD + levels in healthy volunteers ( TABLE 2 ). Of note, there have been more phase I clinical trials using NR than those using NMN, and these have provided conflicting results. One trial showed that short-term NR administration has some beneficial effects in healthy elderly individuals 185 , and another showed positive results in patients with ALS 93 , 186 , 187 . However, NR has shown little to no effect in aged men with obesity 93 , 186 , 188 (see also the discussion in the section Metabolic dysfunction and TABLE 2 ). Therefore, further human clinical studies are needed to determine the proper dose, treatment period and long-term toxicological outcome, together with consideration of the diversity of participants, to better address the translation of the NAD + -boosting strategy. Dietary supplementation The effects of different NAD + precursors on the lifespan and healthspan of yeast and C. elegans have been extensively investigated. In both wild-type yeast and C. elegans , low (micromolar) concentrations of NR extend lifespan in a sirtuin-dependent manner 135 , 189 , 190 . In addition, lifespan extension was observed on administration of NAM to wild-type C. elegans 190 . However, a supraphysiologic dose of NAM (1–5 mM as compared with 200 μM used in experiments with lifespan extension 190 ) has also been associated with reduced lifespan in yeast and C. elegans 190 – 192 . Thus, it is unclear whether NAM administration is beneficial or detrimental in the context of ageing. One potential explanation for this discrepancy is that NAM influences NAD + functions directly and indirectly. Aside from being a direct NAD + precursor in the salvage pathway, NAM is also a by-product of NAD + catabolism, and at high millimolar concentrations it has been shown to act as a feedback inhibitor for NAD + -dependent enzymes, such as PARPs 193 and sirtuins 194 in vitro. However, the results regarding the inhibitory effects of a high dose of NAM were inconclusive in several animal studies 195 . Another possible reason for the inhibitory role of NAM on NAD + activity could be that an increase in NAM level leads to a proportional increase of NAM methylation. This in turn affects cellular availability of methyl groups, which are important for DNA methylation and gene expression modulation ( BOX 2 ). High levels of methylated NAM have been associated with the pathogenesis of type 2 diabetes, Parkinson disease and cardiac diseases 195 . Therefore, further studies are needed to elucidate the safest NAM doses and treatment periods. The strategy to boost NAD + has also been adopted in extending lifespan in age-related disorders. NAD + replenishment, using NR and/or NMN, has also been effective in delaying progeroid phenotype and extending lifespan in relevant C. elegans models of xeroderma pigmentosum group A, ataxia telangiectasia and Cockayne syndrome 33 , 134 , 135 and in a worm model of Werner syndrome (a progeroid disease) 196 . NMN treatment significantly increased NAD + levels and the maximum lifespan also in a mouse model of ataxia telangiectasia 135 . Treatment with NR also improved muscle stem cell functions by regulating mitochondrial metabolism in a mouse model of muscular dystrophy 197 , 198 . Few studies to date have investigated the effects o
Modulation of NAD + biosynthesis
The salvage and de novo synthesis pathways of NAD + are also potential targets for therapies boosting NAD + levels in vivo. Specifically, activators of NAMPT, the rate-limiting enzyme in the NAD + salvage pathway, and NMNATs, which contribute to the NAD + de novo and salvage pathways ( FIG. 1 ), have been suggested as possible therapeutic interventions for boosting tissue NAD + levels 213 . Indeed, the neuroprotective agent P7C3 enhances NAMPT activity and boosts NAD + levels in doxorubicin-treated human cells, suggesting it may be a functional therapeutic for ageing and age-related disease processes, such as neurodegeneration 214 . However, the real efficacy of P7C3 in increasing NAMPT activity remains controversial 215 . Recently, another small molecule, SBI-797812, was proposed as a potent NAMPT activator active in the nanomolar range. This compound increased NAMPT-mediated NMN production in vitro and, importantly, NAD + levels in cell lines and in vivo 214 , 215 . Despite the limited effect of SBI-797812 of boosting only hepatic NAD + levels in vivo, this is a promising pharmacological approach to raise intracellular NAD + levels. Moreover, pharmacological inhibition of ACMSD by TES-991 and TES-102524 boosts de novo NAD + synthesis and SIRT1 activity, ultimately enhancing mitochondrial function in the liver, kidneys and brain of mice 216 . Although these strategies are promising for therapeutic increase of NAD + levels, one of the challenges that remains is identifying with greater precision how some of these molecules, such as P7C3, work at the molecular level, determining their targets and exploring potential off-target effects. In addition to modulating NAD + levels, in recent years, attention has been given to modulating the NAD + /NADH redox balance primarily through the administration of the redox-cycling quinone β-lapachone, an exogenous co-substrate of NAD(P)H:quinone acceptor oxidoreductase 1 (NQO1), which regenerates NAD + from NADH. NQO1 was shown to be increased by caloric restriction (although it was not sufficient to mediate anti-ageing effects of this dietary intervention) 217 , and enhancing NQO1 activity by administering β-lapachone prevented age-dependent decline of motor and cognitive function in aged mice by ameliorating mitochondrial dysfunction 218 , 219 . However, NQO1 is commonly overexpressed in most solid tumours in which β-lapachone administration induces imbalance of redox cycle and oxidative stresses 220 ; therefore, β-lapachone can have a variety of effects depending on the context and should be administered with caution.
Inhibition of NAD + consumption
Targeting NAD + degradation enzymes and pathways is perhaps the most compelling area of recent therapeutic development. Specifically, targeting PARPs and NADases, including CD38, CD157 and SARMs, has great potential to treat age-related diseases associated with declines in NAD + levels. In C. elegans , PARP inhibition results in a significant lifespan extension in wild-type worms 190 , in a model of ataxia telangiectasia 135 and under hyperglycaemic conditions 221 . PARP1 inhibitors, such as olaparib and rucaparib, are marketed as adjuncts to chemotherapy or monotherapies for cancer 222 . They sensitize tumours to DNA damage, but they have limited use due to toxicity 223 – 225 . CD38 is one of the main NADases in mammals and plays a key role in age-related decline of NAD + levels (see the section NAD + -dependent mechanisms in ageing ) 42 . Several inhibitors of CD38 already exist or are in development, a few of which enhance NAD + levels in vivo. For example, apigenin, a naturally occurring flavonoid, enhances NAD + levels in human cells and mouse liver tissue, and improves glucose and lipid homeostasis in mouse models of obesity 226 . More recently, apigenin has been shown to downregulate CD38 expression, and to increase the intracellular NAD + /NADH ratio and SIRT3-mediated mitochondrial antioxidative enzyme activity in the kidneys of diabetic rats 227 . Another flavonoid CD38 inhibitor, luteolinidin, boosts NAD + levels and protects the endothelium and myocardium after myocardial ischaemia in mice 228 . Clinically, luteolin has neuroprotective effects in children with autism 229 , although NAD + levels were not directly assessed in this context. Additionally, several derivatives of 4-aminoquinoline, including the compound 78c, inhibit CD38 and boost NAD + levels in mouse muscle, liver and heart 230 . Compound 78c also prevents age-related declines in NAD + levels in mice, and treatment of aged mice with this compound was shown to ameliorate metabolic dysfunction, reduce DNA damage accumulation and improve muscle function 91 , 231 . Although the study authors did not report lifespan changes directly, they did report activation of the prolongevity AMPK pathway and reduced activation of the mTOR–p70 S6K and ERK pathways 91 . More recently, compound 78c protected against postischaemic endothelial and cardiac myocyte injury in mice 91 , 231 . Overall, mounting evidence suggests that targeting CD38 and related NAD + -consuming enzymes, such as PARPs, has great potential as an NAD + -boosting target to extend human healthspan, and several pharmacological approaches are in development to inhibit CD38 and its NADase activity 232 ( TABLE 1 ).
Conclusions and perspective
Almost 90 years after its initial discovery, NAD + is emerging as a central metabolite in the ageing field, and NAD + level decline is becoming an established feature of several age-associated diseases. The NAD + field is moving rapidly and has evolved as one of the major exciting research areas in biomedical research. In the past 5 years there has been a plethora of advancements, including the development of exciting tools and technology ( Supplementary Box 4 ), to further advance our understanding of how NAD + levels influence or are influenced by complex signalling, metabolic and cellular pathways. Furthermore, with the use of stable-isotope tracing and NAD + biosensors, there have also been major advances and refinement in our understanding of how NAD + levels are regulated both at the cellular level and at the systems level. We now have greater understanding of the mechanisms that lead to decline of NAD + levels with age and the emerging role of NAD + -consuming enzymes such as CD38 and SARM1, along with PARPs in this process. Furthermore, this decline in NAD + levels is now known to affect multiple age-dependent cellular processes, including DNA repair, oxidative stress and immune cell function. Moreover, recent pre-clinical trials have demonstrated, using different animal models, that NAD + depletion is a key pathway in age-associated diseases, including neurodegenerative, metabolic and progeroid disorders. However, it is still not clear which cells and enzymes drive the decline in NAD + levels in specific disorders. Moreover, which targets or pathways can be exploited to efficiently and safely restore NAD + homeostasis is still under investigation. The good news is that different NAD + -boosting strategies have been shown to be effective in extending healthspan and lifespan (see the section Therapeutic targeting of NAD + level decline and TABLE 1 ). Thus, the use of NAD + precursors such as NMN and NR, along with small molecules that boost NAD + biosynthesis or inhibit NAD + degradation, offers an exciting therapeutic approach to treat ageing-related diseases and increase human healthspan. This is particularly important as elderly populations are rising rapidly, and ageing-related diseases are predicted to cause a great deal of societal and economic burden in the coming decades. However, the translatability of NAD + -boosting therapies to humans remains the key question to be answered. Several human clinical trials are ongoing to assess the safety and efficacy of NAD + augmentation ( TABLE 2 ) and, importantly, early-phase trials of short-term NR/NMN administration have proven it to be safe and to increase NAD + levels in healthy participants. However, despite the promising preliminary results, whether long-term supplementation with NAD + precursors has any side effects is still unknown. Moreover, many other questions need to be answered to deepen our understanding of the potential of NAD + -boosting therapies: is there any tissue/disease specificity for NMN and NR? What are the therapeutic doses of NAD + precursors necessary for different diseases? Could the combination of NAD + -boosting strategies, such as CD38 and/or PARP1 inhibitors with NAD + precursor supplementation, be something to consider? Hopefully, the upcoming results of current clinical trials will shed some light on our unsolved questions and set the basis for future directions in deciphering the role of NAD + during ageing in humans.
Generation of NAD + via the NAM salvage pathway
The nicotinamide (NAM) salvage pathway generates nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD + ) from the precursor NAM or the upstream NAD + vitamin precursor nicotinamide riboside (NR) or nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) (see FIG. 1a ), which can be found in a variety of daily foods such as milk, fruits, vegetables and meat 178 , 199 . As NAD + is not cell permeable, it was thought that all the dietary precursors, including nicotinic acid, NAM, NR and tryptophan, are imported directly into the cells and made available for NAD + biosynthesis, with the exception of NMN. In support of this, extracellular NMN must be converted to NR by the 5′-nucleotidase CD73 before being imported, thus creating a rate-limiting conversion back to NMN intracellularly by nicotinamide riboside kinase 1 (NRK1) 245 . A recent study revealed the presence of a specific NMN transporter, SLC12A8, that is highly expressed in the small intestine, suggesting that NMN represents a direct entry point into the NAD + biosynthetic pathway 246 . Further studies are necessary to determine the physiological relevance of this transporter to disease, the kinetics and mechanisms of NMN uptake and those of other NAD + precursors, and their selective expression and effects in each tissue and/or cell in mammals. NAD + recycling via the NAM salvage pathway is a fundamental step to restore NAD + levels after irreversible degradation mediated by the different classes of NAD + -consuming enzymes, including glycohydrolases (CD38, CD157 and SARM1), protein deacylases (sirtuins) and poly(ADP-ribose) polymerases (PARPs). Although the activities and uses of NAD + differ for each of these enzymes (see FIG. 2 ), all NAD + -consuming enzymes produce NAM as a by-product of NAD + degradation; this is converted by the NAM salvage pathway enzyme nicotinamide phosphoribosyltransferase (NAMPT) to NMN. NMN can also be generated from NR by NRK1 and NRK2 (REFS 5 , 245 ) and converted to NAD + during the last step of the salvage pathway by the nicotinamide mononucleotide adenylyltransferases NMNAT1, NMNAT2 and NMNAT3 (REFS 247 , 248 ). Three isoforms of NMNAT have different subcellular localization (NMNAT1, nucleus; NMNAT2, cytosolic face of the Golgi apparatus; NMNAT3, mitochondria) and were reported to regulate NAD + levels in their respective cellular compartment, but also to influence other intracellular NAD + stores 4 , 249 , 250 . NAMPT is ubiquitously expressed and mostly upregulated in processes that depend on high NAD + levels, such as immune cell activation 251 and genotoxic stress 252 . NAMPT-mediated NAD + biosynthesis influences cellular metabolism and responses to inflammatory, oxidative and genotoxic stress 253 , 254 by modulating activities of sirtuins and PARP 100 , 253 , 255 . Moreover, NAMPT expression is regulated by the circadian clock machinery (CLOCK–BMAL1) in a feedback loop involving SIRT1, and this correlates with the circadian oscillation of NAD + levels in vivo 10 , 11 . NAMPT exists in two forms in mammals: intracellular NAMPT (iNAMPT) and extracellular NAMPT (eNAMPT). To function as an NAD + biosynthetic enzyme, NAMPT forms homodimers 256 . Many cell types produce eNAMPT 130 , and its secretion is actively regulated by SIRT1 or SIRT6-mediated deacetylation 257 in adipose tissue and cancer cell lines 258 , respectively. More recently, it was shown that eNAMPT is carried in extracellular vesicles in the blood circulation of mice and humans (see FIG. 1a ) and it is responsible for enhancing the intracellular NAD + biosynthesis in primary hypothalamic neurons 259 . In addition to its role in regulating NAM salvage, eNAMPT was previously identified as a presumptive cytokine (also known as pre-B cell colony-enhancing factor (PBEF)) 260 . The levels of eNAMPT monomer in the serum are increased in a number of immunological and metabolic disorders 261 , 262 . However, it is unclear whether the enzymatic activity of NAMPT is necessary for its cytokine-like function. Therefore, discriminating between monomer and dimer forms of eNAMPT could be a way to resolve the current controversy about enzymatic activity 263 and function of eNAMPT. Collectively, these studies suggest that eNAMPT acts to maintain NAD + in distant cells in an autocrine fashion and, remarkably, also acts as an endocrine signal to influence NAD + levels and inflammation in distant tissues.
Metabolic catabolism of NAD + via NNMT and NADK
Nicotinamide N -methyltransferase (NNMT) is an enzyme that uses S -methyladenosine (SAM) as a methyl donor to methylate the ring nitrogen of nicotinamide (NAM), converting it to N 1 -methylnicotinamide (MNAM) (see FIG. 1a ). MNAM can be further oxidized via aldehyde oxidase to produce N 1 -methyl-2-pyridone-5-carboxamide and N 1 -methyl-4-pyridone-3-carboxamide, which along with MNAM are secreted in the urine. NNMT conversion of NAM to MNAM effectively diverts NAM from being recycled back to nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD + ) by the NAM salvage pathway and affects global NAD + levels. Thus, there has been growing interest in the role of NNMT as a key regulator of NAD + levels during disease states, such as obesity, cancer and ageing 264 . For example, NNMT expression increases in visceral white adipose tissue and liver during obesity, and appears to have mostly negative consequences 265 – 268 . This includes the depletion of the methyl donor SAM and NAD + in white adipose tissue and the liver in response to a high-fat diet. As a result, increased NNMT activity leads to reduced methylation of the promoters of genes involved in fibrosis and aberrant gene expression of metabolic and inflammatory genes 266 . Thus, NNMT appears to be a critical metabolic enzyme linking NAD + metabolism to control of gene expression via its ability to regulate levels of bioactive molecules, such as consumption of NAD + and SAM, to produce MNAM. The role of NNMT in regulating NAD + suggests that NNMT is important in ageing. In support of this, the Caenorhabditis elegans homologue of NNMT, ANMT-1, regulates the production of MNAM. In worms, MNAM serves as a substrate for the aldehyde oxidase GAD-3, which produces hydrogen peroxide, which, in turn, acts as a hormesis signal to promote longevity. Worms lacking anmt-1 no longer benefit from sir-2.1 -dependent lifespan extension 191 . These data suggest that consumption of NAD + via NNMT is beneficial for lifespan extension at least in C. elegans . However, it is unclear what role NNMT activation plays in mammalian ageing, although NNMT expression and activity do appear to increase in rodents as they age. For example, our group recently saw NNMT gene expression increase in the hepatocytes of ageing mice 45 , and a similar increase was observed in hepatocytes of older mice fed a high-protein diet 269 . Additionally, treating old mice with an NNMT inhibitor activated senescent muscle stem cells and promoted muscle regeneration during ageing 270 . Thus, in contrast to C. elegans , in mammals early evidence suggests that NNMT may promote ageing-related diseases. Thus, targeting NNMT may provide a viable therapeutic avenue to treat ageing-related diseases. Another metabolic fate of NAD + is direct phosphorylation by NAD + kinase (NADK) to produce NADP(H), which has a key role as a major source of reducing power that regulates intracellular redox balance and anabolic processes, such as lipogenesis. A recent study using in vitro isotopic tracing label incorporation into NADP(H) showed that NADK accounts for 10% of NAD + consumption 5 . However, the total NADP + pool is 20 times less than the NAD + pool. Furthermore, in conditions where NAD + levels decline, such as in ageing, NADP + levels also decline. Thus, NADP + levels appear to be directly linked to NAD + levels and rise and fall in tandem, making it unlikely that NADK is a major NAD + sink. However, NADK has recently been shown to be a direct target of AKT kinase, phosphorylating the residues Ser44, Ser46 and Ser48 and leading to enhanced activation of NADK 271 . Thus, given that AKT signalling is abnormally increased during ageing 272 , aberrant activation of NADK may account for some of the decline in NAD + levels during ageing. Therefore, further studies will be needed to determine the role of NADK in regulating NAD + and NADP + pools in ageing and ageing-related diseases.
| DOI | 10.1038/s41580-020-00313-x |
| PubMed ID | 33353981 |
| PMC ID | PMC7963035 |
| Journal | Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology |
| Year | 2020 |
| Authors | Anthony J. Covarrubias, Rosalba Perrone, Alessia Grozio, Eric Verdin |
| License | Open Access — see publisher for license terms |
| Citations | 1,398 |